[Insight-users] Code to dis-allow instantiation of itk::Image

[Luis Ibanez]

Hi Hans,

Thanks a lot for looking at this problem and taking the initiative in
a way forward.



        I have no objection to committing the changes.


However, you may want to warn the lists regarding the fact that the
Dashboard will be red for the following days.

I'll be out at MICCAI tomorrow, but will be able to help clean up the
Dashboard starting on Monday. If we all chip in a bit, it shouldn't
take too long to take the Dashboard back to green.


    Thanks


       Luis



-------------------
Hans Johnson wrote:
> Luis,
> 
> As discussed on the TCON over the past few weeks, there is a need to be 
> able to disallow instantiation of itk::Image in order to identify places 
> in the code that will implicitly downcast the itkOrientedImage to an 
> itkImage.  This will be particularly important for three cases:
> 
>    1. Identify places in the current library where filters are creating
>       internal temporary images that downcast itk::OrientedImage image
>       to itk::Image
>    2. Identify problems that will occur when itk::Image takes on the
>       behavior that is currently relegated to itk::OrientedImage (i.e.
>       In ITK 4.0) and itkOriented image becomes an empty shell
>    3. Allow a safe path for application developers transition to
>       itk::OrientedImage by allowing the compiler to verify that all
>       instances of itk::Image have been properly converted to
>       itk::OrientedImage
> 
> 
> Please review the patch at the bottom of this file.  I will commit this 
> patch this afternoon if I do not receive any objections.  
> 
> =============================================
> NOTE:  If ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE=ON, then the first compiler error 
> that occurs is:
> 
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkImage.h: 
> In static member function ‘static itk::SmartPointer<itk::Image<TPixel, 
> VImageDimension> > itk::Image<TPixel, VImageDimension>::New() [with 
> TPixel = double, unsigned int VImageDimension = 2u]’:
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkBSplineDeformableTransform.txx:64: 
>   instantiated from ‘itk::BSplineDeformableTransform<TScalarType, 
> NDimensions, VSplineOrder>::BSplineDeformableTransform() [with 
> TScalarType = double, unsigned int NDimensions = 2u, unsigned int 
> VSplineOrder = 2u]’
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkBSplineDeformableTransform.h:122: 
>   instantiated from ‘static 
> itk::SmartPointer<itk::BSplineDeformableTransform<TScalarType, 
> NDimensions, VSplineOrder> > 
> itk::BSplineDeformableTransform<TScalarType, NDimensions, 
> VSplineOrder>::New() [with TScalarType = double, unsigned int 
> NDimensions = 2u, unsigned int VSplineOrder = 2u]’
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkTransformFactory.h:37: 
>   instantiated from ‘static void 
> itk::TransformFactory<T>::RegisterTransform() [with T = 
> itk::BSplineDeformableTransform<double, 2u, 2u>]’
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkTransformFactoryBase.cxx:67: 
>   instantiated from here
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkImage.h:93: 
> error: cannot allocate an object of abstract type ‘itk::Image<double, 2u>’
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkImage.h:83: 
> note:   because the following virtual functions are pure within 
> ‘itk::Image<double, 2u>’:
> /Users/hjohnson/src/brains2/iplFreeware/unpackdir/Insight/Code/Common/itkImage.h:290: 
> note:     void itk::Image<TPixel, 
> VImageDimension>::RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly() const [with 
> TPixel = double, unsigned int VImageDimension = 2u]
> 
> =============
> 
>       61   // Initialize coeffient images
>       62   for ( unsigned int j = 0; j < SpaceDimension; j++ )
>       63     {
> ** 64     m_WrappedImage[j] = ImageType::New();
>       65     m_WrappedImage[j]->SetRegions( m_GridRegion );
> 
> =============
> This does add a new CMAKE variable option, but that option should be 
> temporary until itk::Image behaves like itk::OrientedImage in ITK v4.0.
> 
> Thanks,
> Hans
> 
> -- 
> Hans J. Johnson, Ph.D.
> Hans-johnson at uiowa.edu
> 
> 278 GH
> The University of Iowa
> Iowa City, IA 52241
> (319) 353 8587
> 
> 
> 
> Index: CMakeLists.txt
> ===================================================================
> RCS file: /cvsroot/Insight/Insight/CMakeLists.txt,v
> retrieving revision 1.311
> diff -r1.311 CMakeLists.txt
> 215a216,221
>>  # TURN OFF itk::Image as a valid type to ensure that itkOrientedImages 
> can be used everywhere
>>  MARK_AS_ADVANCED(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>  OPTION(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE "Disallow instantiation of 
> itk::Image to determine where itk::OrientedImage is not properly 
> implemented" OFF)
>>  IF( ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE )
>>            ADD_DEFINITIONS( -DITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE )
>>  ENDIF( ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE )
> Index: Code/Common/itkImage.h
> ===================================================================
> RCS file: /cvsroot/Insight/Insight/Code/Common/itkImage.h,v
> retrieving revision 1.143
> diff -r1.143 itkImage.h
> 6c6
> <   Date:      $Date: 2008-02-04 12:34:11 $
> ---
>>    Date:      $Date: 2008/02/04 12:34:11 $
> 284a285,291
>>  //The following template functions are invalid if ImageOrientation is 
> forced to be
>>  //respected and defined as in the OrientedImage case.
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>    //This is a pure abstract member function that is only defined in 
> itkOrientedImage.
>>    //  It is here to force a compiler error when trying to instantiate 
> an itkImage.
>>    virtual void RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly(void) const =0;
>>  #endif
> 293a301,303
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>      this->RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly();  //This does nothing, 
> and will hopefully be compiled away.
>>  #endif
> 315a326,328
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>      this->RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly();  //This does nothing, 
> and will hopefully be compiled away.
>>  #endif
> 337a351,353
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>      this->RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly();  //This does nothing, 
> and will hopefully be compiled away.
>>  #endif
> 353a370,372
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>      this->RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly();  //This does nothing, 
> and will hopefully be compiled away.
>>  #endif
> 377a397,399
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>      this->RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly();  //This does nothing, 
> and will hopefully be compiled away.
>>  #endif
> Index: Code/Common/itkOrientedImage.h
> ===================================================================
> RCS file: /cvsroot/Insight/Insight/Code/Common/itkOrientedImage.h,v
> retrieving revision 1.22
> diff -r1.22 itkOrientedImage.h
> 135a136,140
>>  #if defined(ITK_DISABLE_UNORIENTED_IMAGE)
>>    //This is a pure abstract member function that is only defined in 
> itkOrientedImage.
>>    //  It is here to force a compiler error when trying to instantiate 
> an itkImage.
>>    virtual void RespectsImageOrientationImplicitly(void) const { return; }
>>  #endif