[Insight-users] Re: Journal submission gone wrong - probably

[Luis Ibanez]

Hi Gaetan,


1) We checked the submission of Richard's paper,
    it seems that there was a network connection problem
    between the testing server at Kitware and the DSpace
    server at UNC. Zack rerun the test and the dashboard
    evaluation is now posted in the Insight Journal.


2) About posting the source material of the paper, it is
    fine if you find better to put it as a subdirectory
    of the  source code. I would prefer to have it independently
    just because some papers may become large, specially if
    they have images inserted, and because many users may
    be interested in the source code more than in the source
    text of the paper, so they would be penalized when downloading.

    On the other hand, one nice thing about your suggestion,
    is that by putting the paper source text in the same
    directory tree as the source code, the paper can easily
    use the same images as the source code, and in that way
    get closer to the ideal situation where the images in the
    paper are *exactly* the same as the ones you are using
    for running your code. This is probably the best way of
    having *reproducible* papers.


    So... to summarize, please feel free to submit the
    source text + graphics of the paper as a subdirectory
    of the source code submission.

    It is still preferable to have the PDF appart, so
    readers can take a look at the paper before they
    decide to invest time trying the source code.



Thanks a lot for your support to the Insight Journal
and to ITK.



    Regards,


       Luis



-----------------------
Gaetan Lehmann wrote:
> Hi Luis,
> 
> Thanks for your useful report :-)
> 
> The ImageCompare path will be fixed.
> 
> The article is in the archive. It is called Article.pdf. But you're right, it 
> should be outside the tar.gz. Because I've already done that for my previous 
> submissions, I should have advise Richard to do that.
> 
> I think it's nice to submit the sources of the paper, and I'm glad to see you 
> also think so. However, I don't think that's useful to send the paper sources 
> in a separated archive. It's just more work and more archives. Do you really 
> find it useful ?
> 
> About tests, I'm surprised to not see the results of the IJ dashboard. Is 
> there a problem ?
> 
> Finally, the second author (me) appear on the review page 
> (http://insight-journal.org/view_reviews.php?back=index.php&pubid=62) but not 
> on the first page.
> 
> Gaetan
> 
> On Thursday 22 December 2005 16:50, Luis Ibanez wrote:
> 
>>Hi Richard,
>>
>>
>>Another detail,
>>
>>It seems that CMake is not searching for "ImageCompare" in the path.
>>
>>So you may want to add the following line to your CMakeLists.txt file
>>
>>
>>
>>           FIND_PROGRAM(IMAGE_COMPARE ImageCompare)
>>
>>
>>and in the TEST lines replace "ImageCompare" with "${IMAGE_COMPARE}",
>>so the lines will look like:
>>
>>
>>       ADD_TEST(VRMinFCompare ${IMAGE_COMPARE}
>>                              cthead1-vrminF.png
>>                              cthead1-vrminF-ref.png)
>>
>>
>>
>>   Regards,
>>
>>
>>     Luis
>>
>>
>>--------------------
>>
>>Richard Beare wrote:
>>
>>>Hi,
>>>I've just submitted something to the Insight Journal and suspect I've
>>>got it totally wrong. I've uploaded the archive created from Gaetan's
>>>template, which includes all the code, data and the article. I
>>>anticipated that it was going to be unpacked, and the article
>>>extracted, but it doesn't look as though this has happened, so I
>>>suspect I've made a mistake and should have handled the submission
>>>differently. I didn't see anywhere that would allow the upload of
>>>multiple files.
>>>
>>>If I have messed up severely then let me know what I should do to fix
>>>it. The handle is:
>>>
>>>http://hdl.handle.net/1926/153
>>
>>_______________________________________________
>>Insight-users mailing list
>>Insight-users at itk.org
>>http://www.itk.org/mailman/listinfo/insight-users
>>
>>
>>------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>>_______________________________________________
>>Insight-users mailing list
>>Insight-users at itk.org
>>http://www.itk.org/mailman/listinfo/insight-users